What Killed the Dinosaurs?
PrehistoricLab Guides
About 66 million years ago, three out of four species on Earth disappeared in a geologically short time. Every dinosaur except the birds was among them. The leading explanation is that a large asteroid struck what is now Mexico. This guide sets out the evidence for that explanation, the competing idea about volcanoes and the questions that are still open.
The evidence at a glance
Three independent lines of evidence point to the same event. The next sections look at each in turn.
The first clue: A thin layer of clay
In the late 1970s geologists studying rock layers near Gubbio in Italy and Caravaca in Spain found a very thin clay layer that marks the boundary between the Cretaceous and Paleogene periods. Below it lie fossils of the Cretaceous world. Above it the fossils are different. The clay contains unusually high amounts of iridium, a metal that is rare in Earth’s crust but more common in asteroids. In 1980 Luis and Walter Alvarez and colleagues proposed that an asteroid impact had spread this material around the globe. The same layer was later found at many sites worldwide.
The second clue: The crater
A hypothesis needs a crime scene. Geophysicists had noticed a large buried structure under the Yucatán Peninsula in Mexico. By the early 1990s it was recognised as an impact crater about 200 kilometres wide. It is called Chicxulub. Material thrown out of the crater, such as shocked minerals and glassy spherules, matches the boundary layer found around the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean.
The third clue: Samples from inside the crater
In 2016 an international drilling expedition cored the ring of hills inside the crater. The core showed how the crater formed. In 2021 researchers reported that iridium is present inside the crater itself, directly linking the impact to the global boundary layer.
What the impact did
The impact threw enormous amounts of dust, soot and sulfur-rich particles into the atmosphere. Drilling results indicate these inputs reduced sunlight and caused global cooling. Climate and ecological modelling published in 2020 found that an impact winter of this kind would have devastated dinosaur habitats worldwide. Plants that depend on light would have suffered first. Food chains would then have collapsed from the bottom up.
The volcano question
At about the same time, huge volcanic eruptions were flooding western India with lava, building the Deccan Traps. These eruptions released climate-altering gases for hundreds of thousands of years, so some scientists suggested they were the main cause of the extinction or at least a major contributor. For about thirty years the debate between impact and volcanism went on.
A 2020 study in Science led by Pincelli Hull compared temperature and carbon records. It concluded that the gas-driven warming from the volcanoes happened well before the extinction. The authors concluded that the asteroid was the sole driver of the mass extinction, a stronger claim than some other researchers accept. A separate 2020 modelling study found that the volcanoes may even have softened the impact’s climate effects. Not every researcher agrees. Some studies have argued that dinosaurs were already under pressure before the impact. Most scientists now accept the asteroid as the trigger, with the exact role of volcanism still being refined.
Why birds survived
Birds are the one dinosaur lineage that came through. Researchers continue to study why. Ideas include small body size, which lowers food needs, the ability of some birds to eat seeds, which can stay edible after plant growth collapses, or the protection of burrows or shelters. These are hypotheses. The fossil record of the time is thin, so the question is still open.
What we still do not know
The asteroid explanation rests on several independent lines of evidence: a global layer, a crater of the right age and size and consistent climate modelling. Open questions remain about the details. How much did local effects such as fires, tsunamis and acid rain matter compared with the long cooling? Were dinosaur populations already declining? Why did some groups survive in some regions and not in others? Answers will come from new fossils and drilling, which is why we describe this as the leading explanation and not as a closed case.
Related in the Dinopedia
Triceratops, Tyrannosaurus rex, Quetzalcoatlus, Dodo.
Sources
- Yale News (2020), “In death of dinosaurs, it was all about the asteroid — not volcanoes”. https://news.yale.edu/2020/01/16/death-dinosaurs-it-was-all-about-asteroid-not-volcanoes
- The Open University (2020), “Asteroid was ‘sole driver’ of dinosaur demise”. https://www.open.ac.uk/blogs/news/science-mct/asteroid-was-sole-driver-of-dinosaur-demise
- Hull, P. M. et al. (2020), “On impact and volcanism across the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary”, Science. https://science.sciencemag.org/cgi/doi/10.1126/science.aay5055
- Chiarenza, A. A. et al. (2020), “Asteroid impact, not volcanism, caused the end-Cretaceous dinosaur extinction”, PNAS. https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2020PNAS..11717084C
- National Geographic (2020), “Volcanoes may have helped life bounce back after dinosaur-killing asteroid strike”. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/volcanoes-helped-life-bounce-back-afterdinosaur-killing-asteroid
- Goderis, S. et al. (2021), “Globally distributed iridium layer preserved within the Chicxulub impact structure”, Science Advances. https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10244218-globally-distributed-iridium-layer-preserved-within-chicxulub-impact-structure
- Gulick, S. P. S. et al., “From impact to extinction to recovery: Discoveries of IODP-ICDP Expedition 364”. https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/from-impact-to-extinction-to-recovery-discoveries-of-iodp-icdp-ex/
- Natural History Museum Vienna, “Asteroid dust found within the dinosaur-killing crater”. https://www.nhm.at/en/press/asteroid_dust_found_within_the_dinosaur-killing_crater