← All guides

Animals People Mistake for Dinosaurs

PrehistoricLab Guides

To a paleontologist, “dinosaur” names one specific branch of the family tree, not every animal that lived long ago. Many famous prehistoric animals sit on other branches. The mix-up is easy to make because some of them lived at the same time as dinosaurs. Others simply look like them.

A quick rule of thumb

A winged animal without feathers is not a dinosaur. Neither is an animal that spent its whole life in the sea. Dinosaurs lived on land. A few, such as Spinosaurus, may have hunted in or near water, but they were still land animals. The list below goes through the most common cases.

Pterosaurs: Flying reptiles

Pterosaurs such as Quetzalcoatlus are the most common impostors. They were close relatives of dinosaurs. Both groups belong to the archosaurs. The two lines split during the Triassic, more than 235 million years ago. Their wings were built differently from the wings of early feathered dinosaurs and birds, so pterosaurs are best described as cousins, not as flying dinosaurs.

Sea reptiles: Ichthyosaurs, plesiosaurs and mosasaurs

These marine reptiles shared the Mesozoic world with dinosaurs but were not closely related to them. Mosasaurs, for example, were giant lizards, relatives of today’s monitor lizards. They are often shown next to dinosaurs in books and toy sets, which adds to the confusion.

Dimetrodon: Closer to us than to dinosaurs

The sail-backed Dimetrodon looks like a reptile, yet it is a synapsid, a member of the group that includes all mammals. It lived nearly 300 million years ago, about 60 million years before the first dinosaurs appeared. Humans, dogs and whales are living synapsids, so Dimetrodon is a distant relative of ours. What the sail was for is still debated. Temperature control, display to rivals or mates and intimidation have all been proposed.

Crocodile relatives and a giant snake

Sarcosuchus and Kaprosuchus belong to the crocodile line. Crocodiles and dinosaurs share a distant common ancestor within the archosaurs, which makes them cousins. Titanoboa was a snake that lived after the dinosaurs had died out. Snakes belong to the lizard branch of the reptile tree.

Ice Age mammals: Smilodon and the woolly mammoth

Smilodon lived in the Americas between about 2.5 million and 10,000 years ago. It is often called the saber-toothed tiger, but it was not a tiger. It belonged to an extinct branch of the cat family. Every saber-toothed cat is about equally related to all living cats. The woolly mammoth was a relative of today’s elephants. Both lived tens of millions of years after the last non-bird dinosaurs.

Birds: The twist

The dodo and Pelagornis are birds. This case is different, because modern science counts birds as living dinosaurs. The dodo evolved from pigeon-like ancestors. Genetic work places the Nicobar pigeon among its closest living relatives. So the dodo belongs to the dinosaur family tree, but it was not one of the “age of dinosaurs” animals, because it lived on Mauritius until the 1600s. The full evidence for the bird connection is in Are Birds Dinosaurs?

Why it matters

Getting the group right changes the story. Pterosaurs show that flight evolved more than once in reptiles. Dimetrodon shows that “reptile-looking” does not mean “reptile”. Smilodon shows that similar bodies evolve in unrelated groups. These cases are among the best demonstrations of how scientists read relationships from anatomy and DNA instead of from looks.

Related in the Dinopedia

Quetzalcoatlus, Sarcosuchus, Kaprosuchus, Titanoboa, Smilodon, Woolly mammoth, Dodo, Pelagornis.

Sources

Play the game