← All guides

Are Birds Dinosaurs? Did Dinosaurs Have Feathers?

PrehistoricLab Guides

Yes. According to the scientists who study them, birds are not just related to dinosaurs. They are dinosaurs, a surviving branch of the group in the same way that humans are mammals. This sounds like a slogan, so here is the evidence behind it, with an honest account of what is still debated.

The family-tree logic

Scientists classify animals by common ancestry. The group called dinosaurs includes the first dinosaur, all of its descendants and every branch that came from it. One branch of meat-eating dinosaurs, the theropods, gave rise to birds. That makes birds a living sub-group of theropods, the same group that contains Tyrannosaurus and Velociraptor. A consequence is that T. rex is more closely related to a sparrow than it is to Stegosaurus.

The idea is old. Thomas Henry Huxley proposed a close link between dinosaurs and birds in 1870. It took more than a century of new fossils to convince most researchers.

Evidence from bones

Archaeopteryx, found in Germany in 1860, had teeth, clawed hands and a long bony tail, but also wing feathers and a wishbone. For a long time it looked like an oddity. The turning point came in the second half of the 20th century. Fossils such as Deinonychus and Velociraptor showed that dinosaurs had wishbones, flexible wrists and air spaces in their bones too. Features once thought to define birds were found in theropods first. Hollow bones are another trait shared by non-bird theropods and living birds.

Evidence from feathers

In the mid-1990s the first fossil dinosaur with feather-like structures, Sinosauropteryx, was announced from China. It lived about 126 million years ago and was not a bird. Many more feathered dinosaurs have been found since, mostly in northeastern China. They show a range of feather types, from simple filaments to tufts to vaned feathers. Archaeopteryx already had flight feathers with uneven sides, like those of modern birds. Feathers are useful for more than flight. They keep an animal warm, repel water and help attract mates. That is a likely reason they appeared long before flight did.

Evidence from behaviour

Citipati was found sitting on a nest of eggs with its arms spread around it, the same posture used by many living birds to cover their eggs. The eggs lay in a ring with a gap in the middle where the parent sat. This behaviour shows that nest-guarding is much older than modern birds. Some specimens may even have been males, which would match living birds such as ostriches, where the male often tends the nest.

Which dinosaurs had feathers?

Not all of them. Many dinosaurs had scaly skin, including most sauropods and many plant-eaters with beaks. Feathers are known mainly from the small theropods closest to birds. A skin patch from Tyrannosaurus and its close relatives shows pebbly scales over the areas sampled. Yutyrannus, a much older tyrannosaur relative from China, did have feathers. It was a large animal. That makes the T. rex question genuinely open. One idea is that feathers were lost as tyrannosaurs became huge. Another is that the preserved skin patches are not typical of the whole body or of young animals. Either way, a T. rex fully covered in long feathers is not supported by the current fossil skin, but a fluffy chick or some feathering in places cannot be ruled out.

Common objections

“Birds fly and dinosaurs did not.” Most dinosaurs were not on the bird line. Flight evolved only in some small feathered relatives. The earliest birds could probably do little more than glide or flap. Being a dinosaur never meant being flightless, only that flight is one of the things some descendants went on to do.

“Birds are small.” Many theropods were small as well. Size varied widely within the group. Some dinosaurs were smaller than a crow. The birds alive today include the ostrich, which stands taller than a person.

“Dinosaurs went extinct.” Most lineages did, but one survived the end of the Cretaceous. That lineage now includes about ten thousand living species.

What this means for the game

It changes how you can look at the creatures. The dodo and Pelagornis are birds, so they are technically on the dinosaur family tree. The feathered theropods in the Dinopedia are not “almost birds”. They are relatives that give a view of how bird features appeared step by step. For the details of what we know about each, see the pages for Citipati, Troodon and Velociraptor.

Related in the Dinopedia

Citipati, Troodon, Velociraptor, Deinonychus, Tyrannosaurus rex, Dodo.

Sources

Play the game